American Idol: Randy Jackson Wants A Boy To Win Or Something American Idol is really hotting up at the moment, what with all that singing and crying and blah blah blah. But the big question is, who's going to win? It'd be sensible to ask the American Idol judges. But who? Not Simon because his teeth might burn a hole into your retinas. Not Paula because you'd want a legible answer and not the new judge because she looks so much like the photographer from Just Shoot Me that it honestly freaks us out. So that leaves Randy Jackson. And he says a boy will win American Idol. So that's that.